Chateau Musar and the Valley That Made It 🇱🇧
Lebanese wine, the Bekaa Valley, and a red that half the room calls faulty and the other half calls one of the world's greats.
The first thing the glass gives me is balsamic. Not fruit, not oak, but a sharp lacquered note of volatile acidity that arrives ahead of everything else and tells you, immediately, what kind of evening this is going to be. For a certain kind of drinker that note is a verdict, the point at which the glass is set down and quietly never picked up again. For me it is the opposite, the thing that pulls me in, a signal that the wine has something more complicated to say than most. Same glass, two camps. The interesting question is not which of us is right, but why a wine grown on a thousand-meter plateau in eastern Lebanon should taste like this at all when its neighbors don’t, and why it has been dividing tables for as long as anyone outside Lebanon has been paying attention.
The wine is the 2016 Chateau Musar red, poured at cellar temperature (~55°F / 13°C) straight from the bottle. The color is a medium ruby fading to a clear rim, with the first brick reflections of age, though it still looks younger than its years. Behind that opening note of volatility there are black and red cherries, red plums, baking spice and cedar; on the palate, tart red cherry, the skin of a red apple, more spice, a thread of leather, and tannins that are fine and present without ever putting a hand on your shoulder. At 14% ABV it carries its weight without showing it 1. It is, even at this temperature and this early in the glass, a serious wine. It is also unmistakably itself, which is at once the whole problem and the whole appeal. I came to it the way a lot of people do, by accident, poured a Musar by someone who knew better and surprised to learn that Lebanon was making wine worth being surprised by at all.
Start with what is actually in the glass. Musar’s red is a blend of Cabernet Sauvignon, Cinsault and Carignan in roughly equal measure, fermented with wild yeasts in concrete vats, aged about a year in French oak, then left alone for a long time before anyone is allowed to buy it 1 2. The estate bottles without fining or filtering and releases the wine some seven years after the harvest 2. None of that sequence is an accident, and the distinction matters, because the easiest mistake to make about this wine is to read its rough edges as carelessness. Rather, they are the residue of deliberate decisions.
The house was founded in 1930 by Gaston Hochar and it built its style under the late Serge Hochar, Gaston’s elder son, on minimal intervention, very little added sulfur, and a willingness to let each vintage be whatever the year made it, a philosophy the wine world would later learn to call natural and which Musar was simply doing, without a manifesto, for decades 2. The funk you meet in the glass is chosen. Hold onto that, because it is the hinge the whole wine turns on. But a choice that risky only works if the wine has something to hold it in check, and to find that you have to put the glass down and go to the valley.
The Bekaa Valley is a high plain running roughly north to south in the cleft between two mountain ranges, with the Lebanon range to the west and the Anti-Lebanon rising along the Syrian border to the east. Most of the vineyards sit around a thousand meters (~3,300’), some considerably higher, which is the first thing to understand about the wine, because altitude here does the work that latitude does elsewhere. The days are hot and bright, close to three hundred days of sun a year, but the nights fall away sharply, and that swing is what keeps the acidity alive in fruit that would otherwise bake. Mount Lebanon throws a rain shadow across the plain, shielding it from the sea, and the soils underneath are largely limestone and clay. Put those together and you have a place that does not so much permit viticulture as insist on it. The Romans understood this. The temple they raised to Bacchus at Baalbek, in the north of the valley, is not a small building, and it was not built for a marginal crop. Tarek Sakr, who has made the wine at Musar since the early nineties, puts it more plainly, calling the Bekaa “the Bordeaux of the old world.” 9 There is good wine made elsewhere now, on the cooler Mediterranean hills around Batroun and in the south near Jezzine, but the numbers are not close: nearly nine in ten bottles of Lebanese wine still come from this valley 3 4. Whatever else has changed in five thousand years, the ground has kept its opinion.
What has changed is what grows on it. For a region this old, the surprise in the glass is how French it tastes, and the explanation is more recent than the ruins suggest. Modern Lebanese wine effectively restarts in 1857, when Jesuits at Ksara planted vineyards with cuttings brought from France by way of its colonies in Algeria, the first of the imported European vines that would come to define the place 3 4. Production stayed modest under Ottoman rule and expanded under the French Mandate after the First World War, and the grape list that took hold then is the one Musar still draws on now: Cabernet for structure, Carignan for flesh, Cinsault for perfume, the Bordeaux and Rhône varieties planted onto a Levantine plain. The indigenous grapes did not vanish. The whites Obeideh and Merwah are genuinely ancient, distinct, and in places still grown on their own ungrafted roots, a survival made possible by altitude and chalky soil. There is a lovely old story that these two are the lost ancestors of Chardonnay and Sémillon, carried west by Crusaders, and Serge Hochar himself liked to tell it. The trouble is that DNA work commissioned in recent years found Obeideh to be its own variety, matching nothing in the European books 5. The romance is better than the fact, which is often the way, and the fact is the more interesting of the two: an ancient grape that turns out to be nobody’s ancestor and nobody’s child, simply itself, like the wine it goes into.
The dryness that the rain shadow imposes turns out to shape the wine twice over, once in the glass and once in the vineyard. Low summer humidity means low fungal pressure, which means the vines need little spraying. This is part of the reason why so many Bekaa estates farm organically or close to it without making a great noise about it. Musar was certified organic in 2006 2. The main threat that remains in cool, dry air is powdery mildew, held off with sulfur in the vineyard rather than poured into the wine. And because the valley’s calcareous soils and elevation kept the worst of phylloxera at bay, a handful of old plantings here still stand on their original roots, the kind of thing that has become a relic almost everywhere else. The relevant point for the glass is quieter than any of this. A wine farmed with little sulfur, fermented with wild yeast, and aged with a tolerance for oxygen is a wine that has left the door open to exactly the characters most modern winemaking is built to keep out. Which brings us back to the thing in the nose.
So, is it a fault? The honest answer is that the question hides three different things inside one word. The volatile acidity is real, and it is no use pretending otherwise; even people who love this wine taste it, and the producer has never denied that a degree of volatility rides along with the style. Some of what gets called brett here, the leather and the animal edge, is as much a product of oxidative handling and that same volatility as it is of any single organism, and the strands are hard to pull apart in a finished wine. Serge, for his part, declined to fight any of it, and said so. The more useful frame is historical rather than chemical. The aromas we now file under fault, the volatility and the funk, were until quite recently considered part of what fine wine smelled like. A generation ago they sat in celebrated bottles from Bordeaux and Burgundy without anyone reaching for the word flaw. The standard moved. The mainstream decided these characters were defects to be engineered out, and most of the industry followed. Musar simply did not. That makes the wine less an aberration than a holdout, a survivor of an older idea of what was allowed. The last piece is the one nobody can argue you out of: human tolerance for these compounds varies enormously from person to person, which is why the same glass can be perfume to one drinker and spoilage to the next. The wine does not divide opinion by accident. It divides it because it asks each taster a question their own nose answers differently. There is no verdict to hand down here, only an explanation, and the explanation is the point.
The wine endures these arguments. The valley has had to endure a great deal more. Making wine in the Bekaa has meant making it through interruption as a near-permanent condition, and Musar’s own record is the plainest illustration: through fifteen years of civil war the winery kept going, losing only two vintages entirely, the 1976 and the 1984 6. The pattern did not end with that war. In 2024 the eastern Bekaa was among the areas most heavily struck during the conflict between Israel and Hezbollah, and the wineries were caught in it 8. One estate near the town of Rayak was hit directly, its cellars torn open and several thousand bottles destroyed in the first strike 7. Others harvested under drones, sending smaller crews into the vineyards between strikes and reaching fruit they could get to, leaving fruit they could not 8. Musar’s own vineyards were not hit, but the villages and roads around them were, and the damage that did not fall on the vines fell on the market instead, with the winery reporting the loss of a large share of its domestic sales as restaurants emptied and tourists stayed away 9. And still the 2024 harvest came in and was bottled, in the millions of bottles, across the country 10. The fruit in a glass of recent Bekaa wine was picked by someone watching the sky.
Come back to the glass at the end of the evening, after the wine has had hours to breathe and has drifted up toward room temperature, and it is not the one we started with. The balsamic note that led the first pour has not gone anywhere. Whatever the word volatile leads you to expect, volatile acidity does not blow off over an evening the way a reductive, flinty note does. It stays in the wine, and what the air and the warmth do instead is make everything around it grow louder. The red cherry of the cold glass is joined now by something darker, blackberry and black plum, and the earthy leather has broadened to include tobacco and dried herbs. Late and warm and fully open, the volatility that stood at the very front of the cold glass has become one voice in a fuller chord rather than the first word out of the bottle, the acetic bite that the cold made prickly has softened and settled, and the fine tannins have gone softer still.
And that, it turns out, is a beat past the wine’s best *. Warm and relaxed, the fruit tips toward jammy and the acidity gives way, and what the glass gains in integration it loses in tension. The one I would come back to is earlier and still cool, an hour or so in, where the fruit had opened to show red and black at once but the acidity was still holding the line against it and the funk sat in proportion without dissolving into the whole. The wine is at its best while the volatility is still slightly arguing.
Which is the real point, and why the funk is not quite the fault its critics call it. The volatility is Musar’s doing, not the valley’s. Other producers work the same plateau and land nowhere near this, so the balsamic edge is Serge’s choice, not something the ground hands over. What the ground hands over is the other half: the altitude, the sun, and above all the cold nights that keep the fruit’s acidity high enough to carry a risk like that. The place does not make the funk. It makes the funk survivable, and on a good night worth having. A bottle of Musar is a wager the house places and the valley pays out, and the tension between the two is the whole wine.
—
Thank you for reading Road Less Poured and for supporting my work.
New issues land every Thursday morning, one obscure grape, region, or producer, and one good story, with the occasional bottle like this one that divides the room. If that is your idea of a well-spent inbox, the subscribe button is below, and the next pour is already open.
* A note for the curious. I followed this bottle across about 12 hours, starting from cellar temperature (~55°F / 13°C) to the late evening at room temperature (~72°F / 22°C), tasting it at 30-minute intervals for the first 2 hours, then hourly, recording both the ambient temperature, as well as the temperature of the wine. Each pour was a measured 50 grams. For my palate, the best overall balance was achieved roughly 1-1.5 hours into the tasting, the wine around 64°F (~18°C), with notes of red and black fruit together and the acidity still there to balance them. As it climbed toward 72°F, the fruit turned concentrated and jammy and the acidity softened. The balance I had liked at the start was gone by the end, so my recommendation is to serve this between 62°F - 66°F (17°C - 19°C) and not to let it get too warm.
Château Musar, "Chateau Musar Red 2016" tasting notes (producer). https://chateaumusar.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Chateau-Musar-Red-2016-Tasting-Notes.pdf
Broadbent Selections, "Chateau Musar" producer profile. https://broadbent.com/producers/chateau-musar/
Wine-Searcher, "Bekaa Valley" regional guide. https://www.wine-searcher.com/regions-bekaa+valley
Apollo Magazine, "Ripe histories – winemaking in Lebanon." https://apollo-magazine.com/lebanon-wine-phoenicia-bekaa-valley/
Andrew Jefford, "Lebanese wines tasting," Decanter. https://www.decanter.com/wine-news/opinion/jefford-on-monday/lebanese-wines-tasting-346159/
Wine Spectator, "Middle East Winemakers Persevere During War." https://www.winespectator.com/articles/middle-east-winemakers-persevere-during-war
The New Arab, "The damaged Lebanese wineries reclaiming their legacy after war." https://www.newarab.com/features/damaged-lebanese-wineries-reclaiming-their-legacy-after-war
Al-Monitor / AFP, "Lebanon's wine region wrestles with war." https://www.al-monitor.com/originals/2024/10/lebanons-wine-region-wrestles-war
The Drinks Business, "'Always, we are on high alert': Chateau Musar on winemaking in a warzone." https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2026/05/always-we-are-on-high-alert-chateau-musar-on-winemaking-in-a-warzone/
"Lebanese wine," Wikipedia (2024 national output, figure varies by source and treated as approximate). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lebanese_wine
Wine with Seth, "Lebanese Grape Varieties" (WineWiki). https://www.winewithseth.com/winewiki/key-lebanese-varieties-main-cultivars/
Background reference (not cited inline): Michael Karam, Wines of Lebanon: The Journey Continues (Académie du Vin Library).
Incredible write up. Musar is one of those producers that flies under the radar but truly is world class. Now I need to go source a bottle!